Levin Amendment - Who Voted For It?

Judge for yourself. Below (in bold) are the Democrats who voted "Yea" to the Levin amendment that former-Senator Lincoln Chafee (moderate Republican from Rhode Island who has recently written a book to be released in April) wrote about in today's NY Times, apparently to bolster his own reasoning behind his 2002 vote in light of Senator Barack Obama's heavy-handed criticism in last night's debate of those who voted "Nay" to the amendment (specifically his opponent Hillary Clinton).

Curiously, 2004 Presidential candidate John Kerry had voted "Nay" and has endorsed Senator Obama in 2008 versus Edwards and Clinton, both who voted just as he did in 2002.

I wonder...if we agree with Senator Obama and former Senator Chafee on the decided lack of good judgment for those who voted against the Levin amendment, what would that say about John Kerry's judgment now? Is he...or was he naive? (using CNN's Wolf Blitzer's unfortunate characterization, made impulsively last night..the biggest BOO!-raiser of the night from the audience.)

Senator Joe Biden has certainly never spoken against multilateralism. Senator Biden hasn't endorsed Obama or Clinton, but he did vote "Nay" to the Levin amendment while speaking often about the importance of multilateralism.

Categorizing the Levin amendment as what would've been "middle ground" in the question of authorization at the time, Senator Chafee says,

A mere 10 hours before the roll was called on the administration-backed Iraq war resolution, the Senate had an opportunity to prevent the current catastrophe in Iraq and to salvage the United States’ international standing.

Isn't that revising history? It would not have made President Bush disappear. It may have slowed him down, but I don't believe for a minute that it would've stopped him. I certainly don't believe it wouldn't have turned him into a multilateralist in that political atmosphere. It wouldn't have caused Judith Miller to accurately report the WMD story. It wouldn't have stopped the endless on-the-hour echoes of Bush sabre-rattling on CNN and FOX. It wouldn't have caused George Tenet to be brave enough to admit he saw cherry-picking and war-marketing by the Office of Special Planning happening at the time. It wouldn't have stopped then-Secretary of State Colin Powell from giving his traveling terror show at the United Nations.

Does it make Clinton, Biden, Kerry, or Edwards right on the IWR or the Levin Amendment, now that we look back almost six years? If you always take an ahistoric view, they will always look wrong.

Still, in intellectual terms, it's always going to be debatable. Where would Saddam Hussein be today had he not been removed from power? I think it's a fair question to ask, and one that either Obama or Clinton will surely be asked in a general election debate. Perhaps the "Nay" vote on the 2002 Levin amendment wasn't the right one, but is it a lot easier to wag fingers and play superior judge when you took a risk, perhaps at the expense of National Security (knowing just how bad our intel was less than a year following 9/11) and voted against giving the President an appearance of strength-of-sovereignty.

With all due respect, where is Lincoln Chafee today? What caused voters in his state to lose faith in him? He's outside Washington, D.C.....as Barack Obama was in 2002 when he (along with every liberal blogger under the sun) was protesting the Iraq war.

Senator Obama's argument for "better judgment" and "experience" over that of Hillary Clinton by saying he was against the Iraq war while not being part of the federal government is not any different than Howard Dean's case in 2004. It didn't get Howard Dean very far, although being unfairly marked by talking heads as the most left-leaning anti-war liberal, along with one over-amplified and over-played scream didn't help matters for him.

Jonathan Alter made the prediction quoted below back in October, 2006. I've seen Obama campaign manager David Axelrod try to "cash in" (in a ghoulish way) on the point in 2007, when he tied Senator Obama's opinion on Iraq back in 2002 directly in with Clinton-blame regarding the death of Pakistan's Benazir Bhutto..quite a stretch.

Jonathan Alter quote from October, 2006:

On the Iraq war, the critical issue for Democratic primary voters, Obama is perfectly positioned. He opposed the war from the beginning, with an articulate denunciation of the Bush policy as a distraction from the war on terror. In other words, he was four years ahead of the curve. By contrast, John Edwards is in the uncomfortable position of having said he was wrong to support the war. Hillary Clinton is even worse off. She has yet to acknowledge the obvious: that if she knew then what she knows now, she would have voted against the war instead of for it. If both Obama and Clinton run, he would quickly best her on this issue, which all of her "early money" would do little to counteract. LINK

I have to say that I'm not convinced on the "judgment" issue.
See my posting from FIFTEEN MONTHS ago.

(Speaking of GOOD JUDGMENT and Obama, look at what Lambert's got at Corrente. It'll curl your hair.)



Interestingly, Hillary Clinton publically admitted she'd had regrets about her IWR vote in December, 2006.



I offered my own public advice to Senator Clinton one year ago. (Like she'd take it, already..but at least I offered....)
SEE: "Tough Love for Hillary Clinton on IWR"


Final Note: I don't claim to be an expert on Iraq and our nation's history with them, but Juan Cole certainly is a great resource for this kind of insight. See his comments (and partial transcript from the Iraq-talk at the debate last night.)




THE LIST OF DEMS & HOW THEY VOTED ON LEVIN AMENDMENT 2002:
("Yeas" are in bold font)

Arkansas: Lincoln (D-AR), Nay
California: Boxer (D-CA), Yea Feinstein (D-CA), Yea
Connecticut: Dodd (D-CT), Nay Lieberman (D-CT), Nay
Delaware: Biden (D-DE), Nay Carper (D-DE), Nay
Florida: Graham (D-FL), Nay Nelson (D-FL), Nay
Georgia: Cleland (D-GA), Nay Miller (D-GA), Nay
Hawaii: Akaka (D-HI), Yea Inouye (D-HI), Yea
Illinois: Durbin (D-IL), Yea
Indiana: Bayh (D-IN), Nay
Iowa: Harkin (D-IA), Yea
Louisiana: Breaux (D-LA), Nay Landrieu (D-LA), Nay
Maryland: Mikulski (D-MD), Yea Sarbanes (D-MD), Yea
Massachusetts: Kennedy (D-MA), Yea Kerry (D-MA), Nay
Michigan: Levin (D-MI), Yea Stabenow (D-MI), Yea
Minnesota: Dayton (D-MN), Yea Wellstone (D-MN), Yea
Missouri: Carnahan (D-MO), Nay
Montana: Baucus (D-MT), Nay
Nebraska: Nelson (D-NE), Nay
Nevada: Reid (D-NV), Nay
New Jersey: Corzine (D-NJ), Yea Torricelli (D-NJ), Nay
New Mexico: Bingaman (D-NM), Yea
New York: Clinton (D-NY), Nay Schumer (D-NY), Nay
North Carolina: Edwards (D-NC), Nay
North Dakota: Conrad (D-ND), Yea Dorgan (D-ND), Nay
Oregon: Wyden (D-OR), Yea
Rhode Island: Reed (D-RI), Yea
South Carolina: Hollings (D-SC), Nay
South Dakota: Daschle (D-SD), Nay Johnson (D-SD), Nay
Vermont: Leahy (D-VT), Yea
Washington: Cantwell (D-WA), Nay Murray (D-WA), Nay
West Virginia: Byrd (D-WV), Yea Rockefeller (D-WV), Yea
Wisconsin: Feingold (D-WI), Nay Kohl (D-WI), Yea